[WSIS CS-Plenary] Passes - The latest scandal

Mon Dec 1 04:07:26 GMT 2003

Richard writes wisely.  I will probably be just as happy to observe the 
plenaries from the overflow room or via webcast on my laptop rather 
than being trapped in the conference room.  There will be many more 
interesting events to attend and people to network with than at the 
plenaries.  Most of the statements will probably also be placed online 
fairly quickly too, so you are just fighting to be there when it is 
read out.

Rik Panganiban
WFM

On Mercredi, novembre 26, 2003, at 12:48  AM, richard t jordan wrote:

>
> --Hi, Richard Jordan here -- summits and tickets are very funny 
> occurrences. In Johannesburg, there were real problems. At Small 
> Island States in 1994 in Barbados, there were only 50 tickets for ALL 
> NGOs in the plenary, and there was a system whereby when you exited 
> you gave the ticket to the security officer and then that ticket was 
> given to the next person in line.
>
> All summits are different. My own experience in the UN, avoid the 
> opening session, that is the most jammed. After that, most times, 
> everyone gets in.
>
> The World Summit on Trade Efficiency in columbus Ohio was a prime 
> example. HUNDREDS of extra police were brought in.
>
> After one day, when they realized that there were only 2 NGOs present, 
> Bill Stibravy of Intl. Chamber of Commerce and myself, the massive 
> overtime became budget-expendable!
>
> There were no masses teaming to get in. Remember too that this is 
> Switzerland, and that the Swiss are very precise and that there is a 
> RULE FOR EVERYTHING. A friend once saw me drinking water from a juice 
> glass and said "Wouldn't you rather use a water glass?"
>
> If possible, do your best to relax. I have worked with the 13th Police 
> Precinct Community Council for 20 years here in NYC and probably am 
> one of the few NGOs who understand that with security, rules can 
> change and usually do every 10 minutes.
>
> So, be prepared for on-the-spot shift of whatever you thought the 
> rules were and know that it's going to be for 3 days and that we will 
> have to be as flexible as possible.
>
> If this were Barbados and the SIDS conference, I would sit back, take 
> in a breeze and enjoy some local beverrage.
>
> Swiss wine in a wine glass. And Thomas Ruddy, no picnicking!
>
> Best regards, Richard Jordan
>
> --------- Original Message ---------
>
> DATE: Tue, 25 Nov 2003 22:21:15
> From: Meryem Marzouki <marzouki at ras.eu.org>
> To: ct at wsis-cs.org, plenary at wsis-cs.org
> Cc: hr-wsis at iris.sgdg.org, wsis-euc at fsfeurope.org
>
>> Hi all,
>>
>> I've followed the exchanges regarding the issue of passes for the
>> summit. They expresses the latest scandal regarding the process.
>>
>> First of all, this issue has been in formal or informal discussion for
>> a while, at least since early November. I've heard about that
>> informally at that time, and was asked for advice. The latest
>> arrangement that should have been suggested by the CSB was the one
>> recently recalled by Sean, i.e. a fair repartition of half of the 
>> total
>> passes among "families" and caucuses/WG (fair meaning that caucuses/WG
>> can allocate twice the number of passes allocated by "families"), the
>> other half of the total being allocated on a first come first served
>> basis. Moreover, if I well remember, these badges shouldn't have been
>> nominative badges, i.e. they could be passed along from one person to
>> another from the same caucus/WG, under the responsibility of the
>> caucuses.
>>
>> Second, let me recall what I've continuously said since PrepCom2
>> regarding the CSB: apart perhaps for some of them, most are not
>> representative of anything. My organization, which is supposed to
>> "belong" to at least three "families" (Europe&North America, NGOs,
>> social networks or whatever this is called), has never been consulted
>> on anything, apart from the remarkable efforts from Sean and Angela to
>> keep the plenary aware of important decisions being made in our names.
>>
>> Third, most of the "families", as designated by the CSD, either have 
>> no
>> meaning or have nothing to do with civil society. I wont give again 
>> the
>> arguments for that, I'm tired of doing this.
>>
>> Fourth, the "families" are unbalanced and at the same time overlapping
>> : e.g. the NGO "family" obviously includes many more entities than any
>> other "family" and regional groups obviously overlap with "statutory"
>> groups. What is the point then in giving the same amount to each
>> "family" ?!
>>
>> Fifth, it's really interesting to see at the same time the latest
>> tentative to discredit the civil society self-organization through
>> caucuses and WG, coordinated by the Content & Themes group, and its
>> work since the beginning of the process. We have already seen that on
>> this list, short before PrepCom3.
>>
>> Finally, we can say that the CSB has played his role towards the CSD
>> and the executive secretariat as a whole. Not towards the civil 
>> society
>> organizition participating to the WSIS process.
>>
>> The only really fair process would be to provide passes to any CS
>> organization accredited to WSIS (which means at least participation in
>> the process), and, since rooms are limited in capacity, let pass
>> holders in on a first come first served basis. This is enough security
>> ensuring: these organizations are known enough from the huge amount of
>> paper they had to provide.
>>
>> Any additional pass provided to "new comers just for the show" is the
>> business of the executive secretariat, not ours.
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Plenary mailing list
>> Plenary at wsis-cs.org
>> http://mailman.greennet.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/plenary
>>
>
>
>
> ____________________________________________________________
> Get advanced SPAM filtering on Webmail or POP Mail ... Get Lycos Mail!
> http://login.mail.lycos.com/r/referral?aid=27005
> _______________________________________________
> Plenary mailing list
> Plenary at wsis-cs.org
> http://mailman.greennet.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/plenary
>
>
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=--=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
  Rik Panganiban             email: rikp at bluewin.ch
  Special Adviser            tel: +41 22 734 9774
  World Federalist Movement  Fax: +41 22 734 9775
  www.wfm.org                Mobile: +41 76 473 3274
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=--=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: text/enriched
Size: 6280 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://mailman-new.greennet.org.uk/pipermail/plenary/attachments/20031201/31a63915/attachment.bin