[WSIS CS-Plenary] Civil Society press release: new version

[PatchA]

Below is a comments to the press release of Civil society (Sep. 26th, 2003) 
Please check it.

Thanks,
PatchA, Jinbonet

 In this document, text of press release, CS position to WSIS process is not clear. Negative? Positive? or others? So, I'd like to make clear CS position concretely. 
Followings should be included in the press release text.

1. 
=> In whole process of WSIS, we already saw that governments is nearly trying to exclude civil society continuously  from the prepcom I, II even in this prepcom III, and we have deep concerns about government leading process not including civil society. This is a fundamentally problematic to the multi-stake holder approach which the UN has asserted in the WSIS process. For 18 months, civil societies have already contribute many input to WSIS. But the government has not so much concerns about our approach and also our contents. Even the declaration of principles (Version Sep. 19th), we saw it. And we don't agree with the governmental leading process not including whole stakeholders with civil society.

2. At this point, concrete action plans are needed. At least we need to warn strongly to the government process.

My suggestion is followings
=>  If the governments continue to exclude civil society, we, civil society don't agree with  the governments documents, we don't grant our legitimacy to the government document. And also if they continue to do so, we cannot participate in the governmental process of WSIS any more and we don't contribute our input to WSIS. But we have been fully open and are still and will be open to the governments. It is very time for the governments to approach to Civil Society. We will wait for governments' honest approach to us. 

3. And, we will continue to make our own declaration and action plan for the information society. 


-----Original Message-----
From: plenary-admin at wsis-cs.org [mailto:plenary-admin at wsis-cs.org]On Behalf Of Valeria Betancourt
Sent: Friday, September 26, 2003 4:17 PM
To: plenary at wsis-cs.org
Cc: ct at wsis-cs.org
Subject: [WSIS CS-Plenary] Civil Society press release: new version


Hello everybody, 

A new version of the press release has been developed today.  We 
would like you all you review it and make any comments until 11 am. 

Thanks!
------------------
Text of press release 
27 September 2003

WSIS process at PrepCom III

Civil society has come here to share with the governments our own 
vision for an Information Society. We want an information society 
based on human rights. This provides a unique chance for the 
extension of all the values of Civil Society around the globe.

Over the past two weeks, Civil Society has proven that it is a 
vibrant force in the preparation of the World Summit on the 
Information Society. Civil Society has engaged in dialogue with 
government and business, and has expressed visionary ideas and a 
strong position in the negotiations. 

According to Beatriz Busaniche, a civil society bureau member:  "A 
few days ago I met an indigenous person from Ecuador, who is here in 
Geneva at the U.N. Indigenous Forum, fighting here for rights for 
self-determination of his people. He told me that his community is 
not here asking for their rights, nor to seek affirmation. They are 
already living them. They are here for the international community to 
recognise the fact."

In a similar way, civil society has already been building the 
information society, defending our rights to achieve social, 
educational, political, and economic benefits. Communication rights 
are part of human rights. Human rights must be the framework for the 
Knowledge Society, without this, the WSIS vision of an information 
society is meaningless. Even if the outcomes of the WSIS does not 
reflect, at the end of the process, our principles, visions and 
perspectives, we will continue being key actors in the definition of 
the nature and direction of the Information Society, one whose focus 
would be people´s rights. 

As delegates from Civil Society we believe that every stakeholder 
should have an equal voice, and a right to the benefits of the 
Information Society, whether in education, work, leisure, and 
communications. Hence we are disappointed by the continuing 
resistance of governments to include specific text that ensures 
support for community based media initiatives - which will facilitate 
the inclusion of hitherto marginalized communities from the 
Information Society. To date, there has been an overemphasis on 
computers and the Internet, to the exclusion of analogue and 
traditional media.

In this process, for first time, Civil Society has been directly 
involved in the negotiations.  A special effort has been made by 
Civil Society to communicate its philosophies and methods to 
governments and the business sector. Even though the process has been 
fraught and inconsistent, with civil society included and excluded at 
the whim of governments, our experience has been one of closer 
engagement than has been the case at other United Nations 
conferences.  We hope that this is an experience that can be built on 
to ensure much closer involvement of civil society in the design and 
development of the Information Society.

We now have a stronger position, because as the days have progressed 
meaningful communication has emerged. But much remains to be done. 


_______________________________________________
Plenary mailing list
Plenary at wsis-cs.org
http://mailman.greennet.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/plenary