[WSIS CS-Plenary] Re: [WSIS-CT] [Survey] Surveillance Society Status as of July 13 2003

[Adam Peake]

One more thing.

Please take a look at this, and do check the video link 
<http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/south_yorkshire/3039966.stm> (man 
attempting to abduct a young girl caught on cctv.)

I find a real dilemma here.  And if you search for "cctv" on the BBC 
site comes up with some interesting results.

Thanks,

Adam


At 11:13 PM +0900 7/12/03, YJ Park wrote:
>Dear all,
>
>Surveillance Society Status Survey is "work in progress" and
>your responses to this survey will be appreciated. If you have
>further suggestion or proposal, please feel free to share it. The
>collected responses will be used for "Surveillance Society Status
>Report" session on July 16th.
>
>I thank E.W. Lee who has contributed to especially Survey
>Part II.
>
>Regards,
>YJ
>
>-------------
>Background
>-------------
>
>Surveillance Status Survey as of July 12, 2003 is composed of
>three parts; the first part is prepared to gauge the level of Civil
>Society's understanding about surveillance society in general and
>
>the second part is prepared to categorize each community into the
>following four divisions; Red alert(Matrix), Orange alert, Yellow alert,
>Green(human-friendly) according to Civil Society's responses to
>their current situations.
>
>Finally, the third part needs more work and it at least tried to 
>specify action
>plans on the international basis.
>
>--------------
>Survey Part I
>--------------
>
>Q1. When it comes to online registration, how often are you asked to
>provide your real names, real addresses, real telephone numbers?
>a. every time
>b. more than 50 %
>c. less than 50 %
>d. never
>
>Q2. When you are asked to provide your details, do you usually
>provide  your real names, real contact details as requested?
>a. Yes, all the time
>b. No, all the time
>c. It depends on the web site's nature
>
>Q3. Do you think this kind of authentication or surveillance tools
>are "necessary evils" to build  a stable and trustworthy cyberspace
>for all?
>a. Yes
>b. Partly Yes, but the mandatory approach is too dangerous
>c. No
>
>Q4. How many "surveillance tools" are you aware of?
>a. more than 10
>b. 5 - 10
>c. 1 - 4
>d. none
>
>Reference List of "Surveillance Mechanisms" Proposals
>1. National ID Smart card
>2. Real name registration in the online activity 
>3. Real name registration for Whois, global policy
>4. Bio Data/DNA data recognition
>5. NEIS, Education administration database network setup 
>6. CCTV
>7. Surveillance at work
>8. RFID and other Location Determination Technology
>9. GIA
>10. Carnivore
>11. Echelon
>12. etc
>
>Q5. Out of listed 9 tools, which do you think are acceptable
>when they are proposed in your country and which do you
>think are unacceptable?
>Please, list them up.
>Acceptable tools:
>Unacceptable tools:
>
>Q6. Do you believe your governments or business entities can
>protect your own privacy and those proposed surveillance
>tools will be used for the specific purposes such as cybercrime
>reduction as they propose?
>a. Yes
>b. Partly, but such tools should be used at the minimum level
>c. Skeptical, but it is necessary to introduce such tools for security
>d. No
>
>---------------
>Survey Part II
>---------------
>
>I. Government's Surveillance in your country
>
>1) National ID system
>
>(i) Registration (Please, mark)
>a. Voluntarily
>b. Obligatory
>
>c. Register to Goverment
>d. Local Government
>
>e. Non-applicable ( Then, please go to 2. e-Government)
>
>(ii) Number usage
>
>Do you think the ID card's number is protected well? 
>
>when is it used?
>a. in public areas
>b. in private areas 
>
>Is it used in the database which is electonicaly processed?
>
>(iii) ID card
>what kind of informaion does it contain?
>any other function?
>
>(iv) Does your government have any plan to improve the National ID
>system in the future?
>ex) Smart Card.
>
>(v) What is people's opinion about this?
>
>(vi) What do you think about the national ID system?
>a. useless
>b. necessary evil but refrain it(especially the number) from using as an index
>c. necessary
>d. etc
>
>(vii) What do you think about the improvement of ID system(smart card 
>which contains a variety of information, biological information, and 
>electronic
>authentification function...)
>
>2) e-Government
>
>(i) What is the most important part in your Government's plan of
>e-Government?
>
>(ii) Is this process open to people?
>
>(iii) Do people or parliament have the right to participate in the process of
>introducing e-Government at early stage, and do they have the power of
>determination of the projects/ structure of the system?
>
>(iv) Is the structure of the e-Government system briefed to people? 
>
>(vi) Do you think people should control the e-Government system
>in your country? If you think improper, why?
>
>3) Wiretaping, Data retention in the Internet
>
>(i) In your country, is the wiretaping, data retention (if any) well-balanced?
>
>(ii) What do you think about the tendency of introducing new legislations that
>lessen the condition, widen the areas, means...of wiretaping, data 
>retention in
>the Internet.
>
>(iii) How can we cope with the new surveillance technique?
>
>4) Internet Content Regulation
>
>(i) How does your Government regulate the Internet contents?
>Is it proper?
>
>(ii) What do people think about the Government's regulation on the
>Internet contents?
>
>(iii) Do you think your country's regulation on the Internet 
>contents is proper?
>
>5) Independent Supervisory Authority
>
>(i) In your country, does Independent Supervisory Authority exist?
>(If yes -> ii, iii, v, If not -> iv, v)
>
>(ii) Does an Independent Supervisory Authority work well?
>
>(iii) If not, what's the problem?
>
>(iv) Do you think an Independent Supervisory Authority is necessary
>in your country?
>
>(v) What kind of functions the Independent Supervisory Authority shall
>have in order to control the Surveillance implemented by Government,
>Business Entities, Employers?
>
>II. Business Entity
>
>1) Online profiling
>(i) Usually what kind of information is collectled by business entities?
>
>(ii) Is your contry's regulation on Cookie proper?
>
>(iii) What are the consumer's rights in your country in online profiling
>by business entities?
>
>(iv) Do you think the consumer's rights are properly set? If not, why?
>
>2) Telecommunication Service (including Internet service)
>
>(i) Is telecommincation service user's traffic data protected properly?
>
>(ii) Do you know what kind of telecommunication user's traffic data are
>collected?
>
>III. Surveillance at Work
>
>1) What kind of surveillance techniques are used at work?
>
>2) Employee or trade union has the right to determine whether they introduce
>new surveillance system or not?
>
>3) What is the effects of information system at work?
>
>----------------
>Survey Part III.
>----------------
>
>International co-work(work in progress)
>
>1) Privacy protection Principles
>
>(i) Are the guidelines on the Protection of Privacy and Transborder Flows
>of Personal Data(1980, 'OECD guideline') and EU Directive 95/46/EC
>The Data Protection Directive(1995, '1995 EC Directive') sufficient to
>control the surveillance and to protect human rights, democracy and freedom
>in the information society?
>
>(ii) If it is unsufficient, what shall be added or amended?
>
>(iii) What do you think about the necessity of upgraded or amended
>guidelines(post OECD guideline or post 1995 EC Directive)?
>
>2) Please, share your suggestion or proposals.
>
>Thank you,
>
>ÙsSX§’X¬´+p
+

SàÝÛiÿùsSYsz
>þzyþ¶SàºOæj)fjåSËb?ú?rТ)R¡Èz·#åzv«Êm§ÿðÃ,SÇ,¢¸?
>”íz{SŠéz°:
ºg§¶Èm¶ÿnÇ0~+_-«§Ýýþ-Å~¿†æÿnÇ0r¿ÓÞ6÷?û÷</x-charset>_


--